Wed. Nov 13th, 2019

Yes, dismantling the autonomous communities is unconstitutional

Was the head of list for Barcelona of the Popular Party, Cayetana Álvarez de Toledo, who stood up to one of the main proposals of Vox. "Do not give up the regional system, do not give up the pact of 78", replied the candidate to Ignacio Garriga, which repeats at the top of the list by the Catalan capital Vox after becoming the only deputy of the extreme right formation in Catalonia in April.

"Don't throw away the Constitution, it is the best thing that we Spaniards have done in five hundred years, ”Álvarez de Toledo insisted. And Garriga replied that the PP, along with the PSOE, had been the true traitors of the country. It happened in the debate eight organized TV3 last Tuesday.


The Magna Carta guarantees the right to autonomy of nationalities and regions

The PSC representative in the debate, José ZaragozaHe also had a tough attitude with the Vox candidate, whom he accused of fascism and xenophobia when he talked about immigration. But it was Cayetana Álvarez de Toledo who delved into a contradiction of Vox, a formation that postulates "illegalizing those parties that seek to reverse the constitutional order," as Garriga said in the debate, and then defends the dismantling of the autonomous state.

That objective would imply modifying the preliminary title of the Magna Carta, in whose article 2, it says: “The Constitution is based on the indissoluble unity of the Spanish Nation, common and indivisible homeland of all Spaniards, and recognizes and guarantees the right to autonomy of nationalities and regions that integrate it and solidarity among all of them ”. To prosper that reform would need the votes of two thirds of the two chambers, the dissolution of the Cortes, the approval by the new elected chambers and the holding of a referendum for ratification (article 168).


The transfer of powers to the autonomous communities is regulated in articles 148 and 149 of the Constitution and is not an arbitrary decision of PP or PSOE

Garriga insisted on another usual Vox argument, and criticized “the constant assignment of competences to nationalism ”, as if it were an arbitrary decision. The reality is that articles 148 and 149 of the Constitution clearly define what powers can be transferred and how to the autonomous communities.

Source link