The First Vice President of the Government, Carmen Calvo, has expressed her opposition to the draft of the trans law in the terms that the Ministry of Equality has sent them. “I am fundamentally concerned with the idea of thinking that gender is chosen without more than mere will or desire,” said the PSOE Secretary of Equality in an interview on Cadena Ser in reference to the self-determination of gender that it collects the proposal of the department directed by Irene Montero. This text states that the change of sex in the Civil Registry “does not require more requirements than the express declaration” of the person.
The draft of the Trans Law supports legal sex change without the need for medical or psychological tests
Calvo has shown, however, convinced that there will be a new regulation to “expand and protect the rights of particularly discriminated groups” in reference to LGTBI people, but has recognized that there is still “work” ahead. “We will need to work faster, but with criteria of legal certainty,” said the vice president, thus cooling the Equality objective that the law be approved in the first round of the Council of Ministers in the first half of February.
The PSOE made clear this summer in an internal argument its opposition to gender self-determination when considering that the change of sex does not have to always carry legal recognition. That is the new position of the Socialists, who in the past have defended proposals with practically identical wording as the initiative that Montero transferred to Calvo a week ago. The socialist part of the cabinet has distanced itself from this draft and ensures that it only includes the position of United We Can.
“We have to do it with sufficient legal certainty so that the new rights do not imply a reduction in pre-existing rights,” said Calvo, referring to the suspicions that gender self-determination arouses in a sector of feminism and also the PSOE about the possible affectation that it can have for women.
“I am fundamentally concerned about the idea of thinking that gender is chosen without more than mere will or desire, putting at risk the identity criteria of the rest of the 47 million Spaniards,” said Calvo, who has opted that procedure has “guarantees, stability and criteria as the law has in terms of security.”
What the PSOE does not clarify in its new position is what legal requirements it defends that they have to be presented for that legal sex change.
The opposition of the PSOE to the law that the Ministry of Equality has drawn up is a new focus of conflict in the coalition. The spokesman for United We Can, Pablo Echenique, assured this Thursday at a press conference that “it hurts to hear some extremely cruel and aggressive arguments against this vulnerable group.”
Furthermore, the confederal group does not understand the change in position of the majority partner in this matter since it registered an initiative in 2017 with the same wording and defended it until the Report in 2019, which was not approved due to the dissolution of the Cuts for the electoral advance. “It leads us to ask ourselves if this debate has nothing to do with the United being in the Government and specifically in the Ministry of Equality”, concluded Echenique.